| Platinum | Big Head Burger |
| Gold | Oh My Grill |
| Silver | Wilbo Burger Brats & Brats |
| Bronze | Highway 63 Diner |
| Top Pick | A&W All-American Food |
| Top Pick | D & K Hickory House Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Half Pint Saloon |
| Top Pick | Maid-Rite Shop |
| Top Pick | Screaming Eagle American Bar & Grill |
| Top Pick | Southtown Bar & Restaurant |