| Platinum | Cedar Valley Fish Market |
| Gold | Red Lobster |
| Silver | The Brown Bottle |
| Bronze | Dominiques Seafood |
| Top Pick | Amigos Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Highway 63 Diner |
| Top Pick | Montage |
| Top Pick | Rodney's Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Sakura Japenese Steakhouse and Sushi Bar |