| Platinum | 1st Base BBQ |
| Gold | Bobby Qs Hawaiian BBQ |
| Silver | Starbecks Smokehouse |
| Bronze | Highway 63 Diner |
| Top Pick | Blue Barn BBQ |
| Top Pick | Cindy Lou's BBQ |
| Top Pick | D & K Hickory House Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Famous Dave's Bar-B-Que |
| Top Pick | L N R Grill |
| Top Pick | Salt-N-Pepper Food |