| Platinum | The Other Place |
| Gold | Godfather's Pizza |
| Silver | Basal Pizza |
| Bronze | Urban Pie |
| Top Pick | Chad's Pizza Cedar Falls |
| Top Pick | Gino's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Lighthouse Lounge |
| Top Pick | mama nicks circle pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Tony's La Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Villa Italian |